February 28, 2006

Afstan: it's the immature anti-Americans, stupid

Jack Granatstein also indentifies another culprit responsible for opposition to the Canadian military mission: the peacekeeping myth that will not die.
...
...the word "peacekeeping" triggers a series of powerful memories and positive images in the Canadian mind: Lester Pearson's Nobel Peace Prize; a Canadian soldier in a blue helmet interposed between warring factions; the peacekeeping monument in Ottawa, and the widely believed mantra that, while Americans make war, we Canadians keep the peace.

Canadians are fixated on peacekeeping. We believe that Mike Pearson invented it, that Canadians are the best in the world at it, and that if we do peacekeeping, ideally for the United Nations, then we will not need large numbers of troops or much expensive equipment. The idea of peacekeeping as our métier has certainly shaped Canadian defence policy, and not for the better. The billions of dollars that Liberals and Conservatives have belatedly pledged to rebuild the Canadian Forces will take years to make a difference and to undo four decades of neglect...

...Canadians need to consider what they want their military to do in the 21st century. The war on terror is a reality and Canadians are targets, no matter how we try to convince ourselves that the world loves us. It doesn't...The Canadian troops in Kandahar are working to prop up a democratically elected government that is under attack from fundamentalist Taliban and al-Qaeda terrorists. Participation in that operation is in Canada's national interests, and it is very much in the interests of democracy...

[Many Canadians think] Afghanistan is still the Americans' war, George W. Bush's war, and, automatically, large majorities of Canadians believe it must be wrong.

Canadian anti-Americanism is at a record peak in 2006, and this strong feeling colours every question...

...a mature nation....understands reality and faces it and acts to protect and advance its national interests. Peacekeeping is a cherished part of our past and, even if it has dwindled in utility, it might once again become important. But the reality now is one of terror attacks on the democracies and those struggling to build free societies. Canada's national interests demand that we employ the Canadian Forces to help the new democracies and protect the old...

Historian J. L. Granatstein is chair of the Advisory Council of the Canadian Defence and Foreign Affairs Institute.

Perhaps Canadian troops in Afstan should be equipped, to ward off the myth, with garlic amulets--though I suspect crosses would be thought de trop.

Update: A related post at The Torch (warning: concentration required):

Afstan: Canadian officers take command at Kandahar and of Regional Command (South)

But the Canadians will be under overall command of Americans, Lt. Gen. Karl Eikenberry and Maj. Gen. Benjamin C. Freakely, until this summer.

Upperdate: An excellent letter by Alain Pellerin, executive director, Conference of Defence Associations.

Posted by markc at February 28, 2006 10:11 AM | TrackBack
Comments ()